Difference between revisions of "The Anti-list"
From YPPedia
(→Anti-listed for philosophical reasons) |
m (→Familiar (parrot/monkey/octo) shoppe: Original Anti-list thread entry included kraken in familiar shoppe proposal when this was never explicitly suggested by players in the linked threads. Krakens were potential Adventure Island adversaries) |
||
| Line 120: | Line 120: | ||
*[http://forums.puzzlepirates.com/community/mvnforum/viewthread?p=14550#14550 Nemo] | *[http://forums.puzzlepirates.com/community/mvnforum/viewthread?p=14550#14550 Nemo] | ||
| − | == Familiar (parrot/monkey/octo | + | == Familiar (parrot/monkey/octo) shoppe == |
[[Image:Anti-list-philosophical.png]] | [[Image:Anti-list-philosophical.png]] | ||
*http://forums.puzzlepirates.com/community/mvnforum/viewthread?thread=1561 | *http://forums.puzzlepirates.com/community/mvnforum/viewthread?thread=1561 | ||
Revision as of 02:46, 17 September 2013
The "Anti-list" is a list of requested game design features which the Ringers have confirmed will probably not be implemented in a future release.
Reasons for Anti-listing
Based on the Developers' comments on why particular ideas will probably not appear in game, some of the reasons are as follows:
Technical
- The server's performance could be adversely impacted
- Code improvements might allow the idea to be implemented e.g. the maximum number of hearties was increased after Lizthegrey optimized the database query
- Substantial infrastructure changes for features which are limited in scope
Download size
- Incremental client updates should be of a manageable size
- Avoid major expansions of existing artwork
Thematic
- Little to no code changes but the idea does not fit into the game world
Philosophical
- The idea runs contrary to the Developers' vision of the game
Ability to remove hats in tailor rack preview
Automated purchasing of items for poe
- No clicking on your shirt and then clicking 'sell' to get poe
- Cleaver
Black Ship bypassing during wartime
- Cleaver
- However, blockades are not subject to the Black Ship
Brawls having "I'm ready" checkboxes
Breaking up the parlor badge into separate per-game badges
Changing build/walk types
Clothing
Anti-listed for technical reasons
- Bustle/Victorian 'poofy' dress
- Carried items (parasols and such)
- Fancy gloves
- Swapping clothes of the pirate genders
- Waist-length hair, floor length capes
Anti-listed for thematic reasons
- Anything showing chest hair (bare chests are apparently allowed now)
- Bonnet, sandals and warrior woman chain mail outfit
- Jester hats, big shrouding cloaks, male sarongs
- Tattoos, jewelry and other 'minor' items
- Thigh-high boots
- Secondary stripe color on shirts
Anti-listed for philosophical reasons
- Non-gaudy crowns
- Nemo "Because Cleaver decreed it."
- User customized clothing colors
- Nemo "Unfortunately, that would utterly destroy the herb, textiles and clothing economies."
Anti-listed for other reasons
Oversized or simply 'masculine' clothing on females
- Nemo "If you want to dress like a man, play a man. The art's all there."
Items that the Developers have stated are unlikely but possible
- Scabbards, sheaths
Clothing/clothes/items used for bonus/bonuses/increase stat/decrease stat
Continents and mainlands
Day and night cycles
Familiar (parrot/monkey/octo) shoppe
Flotsam moving
- Cephalopod
- Initially intended but had to be tabled due to technical difficulties
Gender changing potion
Greeters
Anti-listed for philosophical reasons
- Answering petitions
- Scheduling shifts
Hearties
Anti-listed for philosophical reasons
- Hearty chat/broadcast
- Remote hearty command
Housing
Anti-listed for philosophical reasons
- Functional crafting puzzle stations to process commodities
- Mass hearty invite into housing
- Standalone housing
Anti-listed for technical reasons
- "Anytime" houses that exist all the time
- Configuring housing to allow entering when the owner or roommates are not around
At current, you can configure your housing to allow various groups (hearties, crewmates, flagmates, or anyone) to come in when you are home without knocking - this entry on the Anti-list only refers to allowing pirates who are not your roommates into your house when there is no one else there. Consider how long the scrolling list of shacks could be if everyone decided to have anytime entry enabled.
Throwing a party at your house allows anyone access via the noticeboard for one hour, even if you are not there.
In-game voice chat server
- Cleaver
- It might require a lot more network bandwidth than what Three Rings Design has available
Jobbing with brigands
Loans
Making the world round when merging two oceans together
Anti-listed for philosophical reasons
- /vwho ship
- Attack brigand missions, keeping charts or pillaged goods
- Choosing which vessel you can board (by name)
NPPs
Anti-listed for philosophical reasons
- Better NPP/swabbies/computer AI or stat increasing NPPs for hire
- Nemo
- Hermes
- Historical note: Skilled NPPs used to be available for hire in the early Alpha period of the game. It led to players going down one of two routes: a few expensive ultimate NPPs or a mass of cheap able NPPs. Neither way promoted playing with human players.
- Can target/team
- Fighting each other
- For example, brigands attacking merchant brigands.
- Cleaver
Numerical stats (loaded cannon number is not a stat)
Personal upkeep or food/drink (required only)
Anti-listed for philosophical reasons
Pets
- Clothes, toys, toy clothes
Prison/jail/thieves/thief of any sort (for non-banned players)
Puzzles
Anti-listed for philosophical reasons
- Basic slide (squares with sliding pictures or numbers etc) or memory puzzles
- Giving some players control over others' ability to play
- Hypnos
- In particular for Treasure Haul, commanding officers cannot:
- Force players out of the puzzle (except by /plank - if a player could be forced out they might leave the ship anyway)
- Completely enable/disable the puzzle
- Arcturus
- In particular for Treasure Haul, commanding officers cannot:
- House bank PoE fountain for wagering carousing puzzles
- More duty unless balancing with existing can be achieved
- Non-consensual on land
Anti-listed for technical reasons
- Watching Swordfight (and Rumble) in real-time
Recycling old items
Religion of any kind
Removal of PvP (player vs player)
Repair of inventory items
Ships
Anti-listed for philosophical reasons
- Ability to pilot/navigate your own ship, control your ship or command ship without a crew or when you don't have the required stats/rank
This is from before navy missions where the only way for non-officers to gain navigation experience was to be ordered to that duty station.
- Lifeboats
- Upgrades
- With magicked supplies going head to head against ships with player-bought stock
This was specifically about greeter pillages although navy ships would likely fall into this category too.
Anti-listed for technical reasons
- Getting the location when the mouse is hovered over the deed
- Peghead
- The /vwho command has been available to provide the same information in a different way since the November 26th 2003 beta release.
Shotgun/firearm/pistol/rifle/any gun at all as an accessory
Underlining names of flagmates in a scene
