Fantasy Island was a contest held in the YPP forums during April and May 2006. Participants were given the simple criteria of designing "an island that seems perfectly natural and untouched by civilized hands when a pirate first arrives at the Dock Arrow, but which reveals a secret to pirates who explore further." Sindaia took first place with her effort "Stormrock Isle", winning a lodestone compass and a place on the island design team. Featherfin took second place with his "Kennit Isle", winning a sleeping turtle and a place on the island design team. All other honorable mentions received a globe or chart of their choice and a place on the design team.