Talk:Trophy

Stop! This talk page is for discussion of the information contained in the article and the presentation of that information. Discussions regarding various trophy requirements have been moved to the archive page. Please use the following thread: Trophy Speculation and Discussion When making changes to the article itself, please follow the instructions below, especially in regards to leaving an edit summary. Thank you.

Some previous discussions have been archived at Talk:Trophy/Archive 1.

Bronze Triketos

It is awarded for being on a ship that sinks 5 Triketoses. As far as I know, it can be on many different forays into Atlantis. Expect a Silver (10-15) and a Gold (20-25) Triketos trophy too. Vypra 9:30 EST time // Maybe more than that, though, I went twice in there with different chars, they both got bronze, and i went with the same captain, and she doesn't have the next one yet greenbarnacl

Protected Page

I've protected the page from edits due to the repeated addition/removal of information regarding the Bellator's Bane trophy. I'm hopeful that consensus for this trophy can be achieved soon, but the cycle of edits and reversions is not the right way to do this. If other trophies are discovered during this time, please note them in the forum thread and they will be added by an administrator. --Barrister 17:11, 7 September 2007 (PDT)

I still see lots of "stupid" edits (always the same) and then reverted by other peoples, this page is no more lock? if it isn't , it should be again. Because when i come here i check the history to see if there is something new and it is annoying to always see some edit which need to be reverted each time. --Taiioo 05:16, 12 October 2007 (PDT)

Bellator's Bane

Just a sugeestion, Tessebess on the Viridian has this trophy.. you may want to consider asking her how she got it.

Please see the last few pages of this thread. More than 15 people have posted "how they received" this trophy, and so far there is no consensus. --Epimetheus ^(t/c) 06:22, 9 September 2007 (PDT)

Alright, i got this trophy on hunter and i got it after succesfully defeating a dragoon in a 1-on-1 challege three times.

Winning at least 5 dragoon frays?

Hair of the Dog

http://sage.puzzlepirates.com/yoweb/trophy/?pirate=Gracieloo

New trophy no idea how she got it

I got it when I logged on today. It happened after two of my rags crumbled, although I think it has something to do with floating, as I have done 500+ leagues of floating recently, and I know someone who has it on their floating alt. I doubt it has anything to do with drinking, as I haven't done the puzzle for months.

--Matthebeard 12:13 AM (PDT)12 September, 2007

In my searches for background information I found that at the page(http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hair_of_the_dog) right at the bottom in "In popular culture" it says: "In Yohoho Puzzle Pirates, players are awarded a trophy called Hair of the Dog for sailing for a specific amount of time while under the effects of rum sickness." Seems right, and I'm sure someone knows that, but hasn't posted it here, so therefore I am :)You could test the exact time to find it simply by making an alt and hanging around, but the amount of time it took me (10-20 hours or so) I simply don't have the patience. If someone does try this, I would recommend documenting League Points as well as the time, as you float.

--Matthebeard 11:56 AM (PDT)12 September, 2007

Err, yeah, that was me who put that up on Wikipedia, based on speculations I've read on the forums and discussions over Vent amongst several flags. If the true criteria is different, I'll most likely change the Wikipedia article to reflect this. --InvaderJim42 03:34, 13 September 2007 (PDT)

~ I was also awarded this trophy when I logged on. The pirate is only used for floating ships, so I am very sure the trophy has something to do with the amount of time one spends on a ship with no rum.

        Blackstash on Viridian

Fencer and Scrapper

Caribbeano has no idea how she got them, but beleives they are related to Atlantis. I have no clue.

http://sage.puzzlepirates.com/yoweb/trophy/?pirate=caribbeano

Tested on a brand new alt. After completing only the level 1-10 challenge, I received the Scrapper. No additional matches necessary. Logs posted in the speculation thread. --Epimetheus ^(t/c) 20:55, 11 September 2007 (PDT)

--

I just obtained a fencer trophie when i came back from atlantis, i guess i was cuz i just fought some dragoons. check the link: http://hunter.puzzlepirates.com/yoweb/pirate.wm?target=Anthonny.

--Anthonny 6:23 PM (PDT)12 September, 2007

--

I've just obtained the Fencer, Scrapper and Barfly trophies. All were awarded after beating the level 10 bot in the palace from their respective missions, 5 times each. The wins did not have to be consecutive, nor did I have to win 5 times in a row. (that rumble one was a tart) The trophies were given out after the bot had left the room after the fifth winning fight for all three.

Jainasolo 11Pm September 12, 2007

--

Granted I was already on the number 10 challenge on drinking, rumbling and swordfighting but recieved the barfly, scrapper, and fencer trophies after doing each one 5 times per; respectively.-- Haywoodx^(t/c) 23:05, 12 September 2007 (PDT)

--

The fencer trophy is definitelly obtained after SIX wins against the level 10 bot. I tested twice with two fresh alts. The first win (the one when you advance from 9 swords master to 10 swords) doesn't count. Guys who got it after 5 wins have previously defeated the level 10 bot.

Roofiyohoho 01:34, 13 September 2007 (PDT)

--

Roof, that sounds possible for the swords one. I'd already completed the level 10 one for sword (though don't know how many times) and got it in 4 wins yesterday. The rumble (started at #4 challenge) and drining (started at #3) were definitely awarded after the 5th fight at level 10 for each.

• edit* No, I just tried the fencer with an alt who had not played any matches. She got it after her 5th level 10 win. That included the "first" win when completeing the set.

Jainasolo 9:32 AM, September 13, 2007 (pdt)

--

I definatly know how to obtain these with no question asked 100% guarunteed... the method to get this is you have to acheve level 10 in anyone of the drinking, swordfighting or rumble mission then you must have beeten level 10 5 times to acheve this.

Instantflash 11:17 AM, September 13, 2007 (pdt)

scrapper, barfly, and fencer can be obtained by beateing a lvl 10 teacher 6 times.

--

I've beaten the level 10 rumble teacher far more than 6 times but have yet to receive the scrapper. Though, admitedly, I am no good at rumble and there were more losses than I cared about counting between those wins, so maybe it has to do with win percentage or consecutive wins against the lvl 10 teacher

Hatchetback, 1:54pm, September 13, 2007 (ptd)

--

Regarding the fencer. Definitelly the "play with swords" mission counts towards those 15 wins. But only once. I got it after 9 wins against level 1-9 teachers, "played with swords" twice then 5 more wins against level 10 bot.

Roofiyohoho 01:35, 20 September 2007 (PDT)

--

Either the trophy counts wins prior to its release, or it is not for "winning 15 X challenge missions". I got it using the "swordfighting challenge:X" missions. I fought nine different bots, had a total of 18 matches (lost against one eight times, lost to another once), before being awarded the fencer trophy. Chat logs are available. hydranoisp 12:40, 22 September 2007 (PDT)

--

Of course it counts. If for example you're at "defeat level 7 swordfight" mission it automatically means that you've already defeated level 1-6 bots, thus you have 6 wins.--Roofiyohoho 00:43, 23 September 2007 (PDT)

Silver Triketos

may we change the description of this award to something like "Awarded for being on a ship that sinks a currently unknown amount of Triketos." (this sugestion stands for any other awards that will meet a simular description) thank you

fortytwo 20 september 08:10 PDT

I received the Bronze Triketos trophy without sinking, Its probably the same with Silver Triketos trophy that you can get it without sinking. You're probably thinking that its different because of the 'high' requirements for silver

Jim38 25 september 04:51 PDT

Spacing

Please fix the spacing on the first line under Miscellaneous Trophies. Thanks! Sashamorning 10:51, 23 September 2007 (PDT)

Section breaks

I'm not sure why, but this seems much, much wordier than it used to. I'd appreciate it if something were done to address that, along with adding clearer section breaks. -- Thefirstdude ^(t/c) 14:20, 23 September 2007 (PDT)

Here's the old page: http://yppedia.puzzlepirates.com/index.php?title=Trophy&oldid=283357 Feel free to provide examples of how the new version is wordier. I added a couple of introductory paragraphs, but I removed a substantial amount of repetitive text. Take a look at the blockade maneuver trophies and the ultimate/#1/incredible trophies.

Also, I've unlocked the page, so feel free to tweak the section breaks yourself. --Barrister 19:27, 23 September 2007 (PDT)

Adressing two issues here... (1) This layout version looks great. I really like it, it's less ambigious, and gives more at just the first glance at it. (2) One problem is that the first row on each of the grid-layout sections (Misc and Atlantis) seems to lose the text-align:center and stick to the left (obviously this disappears when we resize the browser window to smaller). I was thinking to fix it but i'm not that good at this stuff.. Maybe the trophy display template is unaligned or wrongly aligned?... Furiss 06:59, 24 September 2007 (PDT)

Gold Digger

11 gold ore? Here is the in-game source. --Epimetheus ^(t/c) 10:23, 25 September 2007 (PDT)

Miscellaneous Trophies table adjustment

I just want to say that the active Miscellaneous trophies (Unchiseled Potential) and and Miscellaneous trophies that are no longer available (Like the pink heart and ship in a bottle) should be separated in two different tables. The no longer available trophies should be at the bottom of the page, because they are not that interesting.

MrNoHelp 21:58, 25 September 2007 (CET)

Columns

Please try, for a given table, to keep the columns an equal width. --Barrister 21:09, 28 September 2007 (PDT)

Also, please try to keep the appearance of the tables consistent. Avoid having some with shadowed borders and some with thin lines. If you're going to experiment, I suggest using a private sandbox. Thanks! --01:55, 29 September 2007 (PDT)

Zombie trophies

This is mostly a note to myself. The "Zombies-Bane" trophy is almost certainly named wrong, but I'm just going to let it sit there until the bug fix comes that straightens it all out. --Barrister 21:14, 27 October 2007 (PDT)

FYI, from Ice Changelog "2007-10-26 - Fix booched zombie trophy names." Klostro 07:28, 29 October 2007 (PDT)

Wow! I jus found a new Zombie trophie that has yet to be added to the page!! I found it on Monkeyluffyd's Pirate Page (Viridian), Ill post a picture of it:

(picture already exists on trophy page, duplicate image deleted)

Thank Ye! Add it soon! --Instantflash 07:57, 8 November 2007 (PST)

This was awarded coming 3rd place in the Ye Dread Dead event and is already on the trophy page --Shadowjohn3 08:00, 8 November 2007 (PST)

#1 Carouser?

I've reverted the edit that claimed that there was no #1 Carouser trophy. We need to see a pirate with all the #1 trophies for each carousing puzzle before we can rule this one out. --Barrister 20:44, 2 December 2007 (PST)

Check Xelliana on Cobalt. She's got all #1 trophies for the carousing puzzles and there is no #1 Carouser trophy.

--Lannisters 9:16, 5 December 2007 (PST) Custer/Lannister on Cobalt

To achieve any of the #1 trophies you have to be #1 on the ultimate list. Wouldn't it follow that to be #1 carouser you would have to be #1 on all of the ultimate lists? -- Cedarwings ^(t/c) 22:17, 5 December 2007 (PST)

Thanks, Lannisters! It's clear that Xelliana has, at various times, held the #1 spot for all carousing puzzles without earning a #1 carouser. --Barrister 23:02, 5 December 2007 (PST)

Jade Monkey?

There has been found a Jade Monkey. Go to this URL page and theres a like on the page to someone's trophy page. Head to that and its on that: http://forums.puzzlepirates.com/community/mvnforum/viewthread?p=1333807#1333807 --langcam

Reindeer Games Trophies

I uploaded some of the Reindeer Games Trophy Images.

When Sleigh Captain, , Booty-filled Stocking, , Sack of Flight Powder, , Ornamental Cabin Elf, , Reindeer Feed, , Nose-glow Wax, ,Proto-diamond,, and Bushel of Reindeer Apples, get uploaded, someone can put together a properly formatted row in the Competition section.