User talk:Lofwyr/Sandbox/Jinxed Idol Speculation

The YPPedia is not the place for trophy speculation. There is a reason it's forbidden in the Trophy article. Also, at no time in the past has there ever been a page created purely to speculate on a trophy (and there are some pretty odd trophies in the mix). --Thunderbird 03:19, 20 March 2008 (PDT)
 * I can understand the desire to have a single page with all the theories and information. Discussion in the thread is already several pages long and I have my forum set for more posts per page than the default.  I'll just move this to Lofwyr's sandbox. --Fiddler 03:43, 20 March 2008 (PDT)
 * This is a perfectly sensible use for a user page. Discussion belongs on the forum, but this one is a tough nut to crack and we need to track our theories properly.--Lesleywalker 05:42, 20 March 2008 (PDT)

Posting forum links
When citing specific posts from the forum, use the message specific form that ends "..../viewthread?p=1457354#1457354</". This can be found to the left of the message timestamp, a small brown icon. The other form is dependent on the messages-per-page setting of the user. --Lesleywalker 19:04, 23 March 2008 (PDT)

Mis-entered pirate names
These pirates are are claimed to have to have received it, but their pirate pages don't work or the trophy isn't listed, so they are assumed to be spelt wrong, or listed for the wrong ocean. Therefore they have been moved from the article to here.


 * (Toosie) - Viridian - 2008-03-23
 * Topgun (Midnight) - 2008-03-17

New theory
Added the "Deja Vu" theory to the theorys section.

Multi-awardees
Seeing as this isn't all that new; I think extracting what these pirate have in common deserves closer inspection.


 * Vavavoomm (Midnight/Ice) says he she has two pirates with the trophey. I'll try to contact both.
 * Babjanova (Viridian/Cobalt) has it twice. --mwagner 21:27, 01 October 2008 (PDT)

Sounds worthwhile investigating to me. Unfortunately I'm really short on spare time to do any investigating at the moment, but things should ease up a bit about the end of November. --Lesleywalker 00:07, 9 October 2008 (UTC)


 * Hi! I (Adrielle) won this trophy on Ice after a pillage in which I attacked and lost to the widow queen twice. I also won it on Opal after a pillage (we did not get a brigand king, though). This makes me think it has something to do with being on a ship! lol =) (I know, not particularly helpful). I am a bit sad that I haven't won this trophy on my main ocean yet... Adrielle =) 12:39, 22 September 2009 (UTC)