User talk:Duker89

Shark Raiders
The cleanup tag is probably there mostly because you have the officer and ship lists; generally, you want to limit the information in a crew page to what appears on the infobox, and the crew's history and public statement (a ship list could be on the page if it was part of the actual public statement). --Emufarmers 10:51, 25 April 2006 (PDT)

(Response) The cleanup tag was there before I added the ship/pirate lists. It probably is there because the History part was in a single paragraph.

And the cleanup thingy isn't about the content, it is about the readability, right?
 * Well, then you can probably take off the tag (someone'll put it back if it needs to be there). As for what the cleanup tag is for...Well, it can be about readability, but it's making the article conform to "a higher standard of quality," so it can also be about the article's structure or the validity of its content.  Of course, that subjectivity in meanings is a good reason to make use of the cleanupfor tag instead of the regular cleanup tag if there's likely to be confusion a few months down the line. --Emufarmers 11:28, 25 April 2006 (PDT)