Talk:Brawl

Stub?
Question - why does this have a stub template? There's nothing to add. --VPeric
 * Then hit edit and destub it :) --Guppymomma 14:04, 10 August 2005 (PDT)
 * Right then. Just wondered if I'm allowed to do that. ;) --VPeric

Rumble?
Rumble uses the same premise for brawling, so should Rumble be a parenthetical in this article? Or better yet, have it's own Brawl_(Rumble), then rename this one to Brawl_(Swordfight) and create a disambig page? Reminds me of the whole Brigand vs. Barbarian thing, so I'm not sure. Edit: nevermind, answered my own question and I've modified this article. Need a rumble brawl image to go with the SF one though. --Rixation 07:38 07 April 2006 (PST)
 * Added rumble image, not sure if it's needed, but I think it fits... --Rixation 17:22 07 April 2006 (PST)

Rated?
Are brawls rated? If not, then we should indicate this in the article. (I'm willing to do so; just need confirmation either way, first...) -- Franklincain (t/c) 15:22, 9 July 2012 (PDT)


 * Never mind, found it already in the article. (Need new eyeglasses.)  :-P
 * -- Franklincain (t/c) 15:24, 9 July 2012 (PDT)


 * Brawls are never rated, because brawls are always multiplayer. There is no such thing as a one-on-one brawl. Therefore I question the wisdom of including this exception in the article, it does not belong there. Chupchup 16:23, 9 July 2012 (PDT)


 * I just checked. You actually can do a 1-vs-1 brawl via an Inn's Brawl table, and you can make that brawl rated.  Here's the picture that I captured.  -- Franklincain (t/c) 17:03, 9 July 2012 (PDT)
 * I'm not so sure. Since the beginning, Brawl has been specifically documented as team-vs-team, as opposed to 1-on-1. True, you can set up a 1-on-1 at the "Brawl" table, but I always understood 1-on-1 to be known as a "challenge" just like the puzzle challenge when you click on another pirate in a scene. I am not sure if there is any guidance from the official documentation in this regard. Chupchup 16:32, 2 August 2012 (PDT)


 * The Official Documentation differentiates between swordfighting and brawling, and the brawling page specifically says "teams of pirates". --Fannon 19:16, 2 August 2012 (PDT)

Defend in Rumble only? Not in SF?
I seem to recall seeing someone being defended during a SF brawl (a fray, specifically; don't recall if fray was vs undead or in SMH). Is this article correct; or is my recollection correct? Can someone verify either way, please? Thanks! -- Franklincain (t/c) 10:45, 28 July 2012 (PDT)


 * I have similar (very) vague memories, but they're fuzzy enough that I'm reasonably certain it's just my mind playing tricks on me. It's definitely not possible in standard sea battles or Skellie fights, and I imagine that if it were possible elsewhere we'd have heard some chatter about it (not that defending in brawls comes up often) or noticed it happening from time to time.


 * If nothing else, if it were an option in insert specific SMH type environment here there would be forum threads popping up to the effect of "OMG please make this puzzle mechanic universal" because... defense, ftw.


 * Basically, I don't think it's ever happened, and the memory circuits of the human brain are a fantastic and oft-faulty mystery to us all. (But if it did, it happened somewhere odd and "non-canonical" like Puzzle Pirates Adventures or offline mode in the boxed set.  (But then again, I'm only a mid-level pirate and don't get invited on many SMHes, so... maybe?  But I really, really don't think so.  Watch me totally fail to clear anything up!)) --Ladodal 11:37, 28 July 2012 (PDT)