Talk:Duty puzzle scoring

Agreed that merging this with Puzzle scoring does seem like a good idea. However there also seems to be some contradictory information here (about the basic idea how puzzles are scored), so I don't yet know what to do with that. I can volunteer to try and merge this to the Puzzle scoring -page, probably some time next month. (Of course as this is a wiki if someone else has a sudden rush of inspiration, go right ahead. :) But if not, I will do it myself.) That is if there are no objections to the merge. --Ileden 14:26, 29 December 2006 (PST)
 * I think they should not be merged. Instead, I believe that puzzle scoring should be more like a disambiguation page into duty puzzle scoring (this one) and craft puzzle scoring (non existent as of right now).--Arminius 14:35, 29 December 2006 (PST)
 * One option would be to use "Puzzle scoring" as a general article that describes puzzle scoring in general. The article would talk about duty puzzle scoring (currently this Duty puzzle scoring article), crafting puzzle scoring (currently nonexistent), carousing/multiplayer puzzle scoring (currently nonexistent) and their differences. Then there would be a strong link from that atricle to a new article "Puzzle scoring chart" or somesuch, that would then contain the details that Puzzle scoring currently contains. --Ileden 06:56, 8 January 2007 (PST)
 * Some of the information here is just plain wrong, wheras puzzle scoring is, as far as I know, pretty good right now. I'd go for simply deleting this page and putting more work into puzzle scoring- there's nothing here that Puzzle Scoring really needs from my point of view.. --Diamondblade 07:50, 21 June 2007 (PDT)

Why not do a small heading for duty puzzle scoring in puzzle scoring, but have a link for the full article as well in case you want to see more, like in wikipedia (I mean, the YPPedia IS a spoof on wiki).

--Redro6 14:21, 15 June 2007 (PDT)