Talk:PvP Crew Hall of Fame on Emerald

What basis in reality?
What criteria (if any) are you using for determining whether or not any specific crew goes into this "hall of fame" of yours? The only OFFICIAL records of fame on Emerald would be here (for Crews) and here (for Flags). And unless there is a consistent need for this kind of tracking on ALL oceans (and not just your ocean), I do not see sufficient reasons for keeping this in the Yppedia. (In other words, this appears to be another article you should be hosting on a personal website of your own, INSTEAD of the Yppedia.) Please provide your reasons for why this page should be kept here. -- Franklincain (t/c) 10:52, 23 August 2012 (PDT)


 * How "PvP Crew Hall of Fame on Emerald" could be read as "Crew Fame", which isn't even named "Hall". Your deletion request is ridiculous. This page has purpose to show the best performance of all PvP crews reached Imperials/Illustrious standing. Before edit "discuss this page" read first the page. --Deltaruler Oct 15, 2012 3:10:55 PM PDT on the Emerald ocean.


 * Consensus has not been reached whether the article should be deleted or not. I've restored the notice accordingly. Please do not remove the notice without reaching a consensus. Thank you. -- Faulkston 17:29, 15 October 2012 (PDT)


 * Oppose deletion, but also recommend some improvements.
 * (1), Official PP data has been used to build and maintain the list (i.e. the imperials/illustrious ratings of the crew in-game), and the list seems to have been maintained well, so this is not a problem.
 * (2), the issue of this page only tracking Emerald achievements might be better solved by creating lists for other oceans too (and having other people maintain them) instead of deleting this one list.
 * (3) With regard to official recognition and also (2), moving the page to something like Unofficial Emerald PvP Crew Hall of Fame would be a solution. There exist lots of unofficial lists on the wiki already, one that comes to mind is records.


 * Recommeded improvements for this page:
 * Remove chronological achievement listing from Feb 1, 2012, so that all crews who have attained imperials/illustrious and share the same place are equal on the list. For instance, there is no way to determine that Cubelets' #1 position was any lower or higher than UEFA Champions League's #1 position for instance, so they should share joint #1 place. Two crews attaining #3 place should also share that place and should not be listed in the order that they achieved it. Currently the list is biased towards the creator of this page, as his crew will never leave the top spot when in fact three crews ought to share the same position.


 * {| border="2" style="border-collapse:collapse;"

!Suggested layout
 * # 1. UEFA Champions League, Cubelets , The Black Pearl Crew
 * # 3 - Virtute et Armis -, Neptuns Raecher
 * }
 * # 3 - Virtute et Armis -, Neptuns Raecher
 * }


 * Screenshots could be tidied up with sections and links to those sections listed after the crew's name.


 * --Therobotdude 06:42, 31 December 2013 (PST)