Will o' Wisp
From YPPedia
A Will o' Wisp is a trinket awarded to experienced players1 by Barnabas the Pale upon defeating him in sea battle. It will be inscribed with the message, "Ransomed by Barnabas the Pale to <Pirate> on <date>." Available in these seven colors, it can be held in a portrait by the pirate who originally won it.
1 On doubloon oceans, the player must be holding at least a Pirate badge. On subscription oceans, the player must be subscribed.
